Where to find pull tabs

Pull tabs in New Castle, Indiana

New Castle has 4 spots on the Indiana Alcohol and Tobacco Commission's Type II gaming records for pull tabs, plus 4 listings nobody has confirmed yet. Here's every place we know about.

Checked against the Pull Tab Finder database, November 2026.

Find the closest ones in the free app

Download on the App StoreGet it on Google Play
Spots to play
4
Unconfirmed listings
4

Every pull-tab spot we know in New Castle

  • Buffalo Wild Wings

    1715 S Memorial Dr

  • Hilby's Bar & Grill

    1718 'i' Ave

  • Old Ice House Tavern

    1550 Walnut Street

  • The Back Porch Bar

    1414 Broad Street

4 more New Castle listings are in the database without evidence of tabs, mostly clubs and posts we know exist but nobody has reported on. They stay off this page until someone who's been inside confirms them in the app.

How we know, and what we might be missing

The state-licensed spots above are bars the Indiana Alcohol and Tobacco Commission has endorsed to sell pull tabs: Indiana's Type II gaming law lets a licensed tavern sell pull tabs, punchboards, and tip boards in its bar area, and the state publishes who holds the endorsement. Players in the app confirm what's actually on the bar and add the places any list misses.

A list is honest about its limits: a licensed spot can retire its game, and a bar this page has never heard of can start one tomorrow. If you know a New Castle spot that's missing or wrong, add or fix it in the free app. That's how the map stays true.

Pull-tab cities near New Castle

Or browse every city on the Indiana page.